AVERAGE HOME PRICES
AVERAGE HOME PRICE
per SQ. FT.AVERAGE HOME STATISTICS
IN TERMS OF:
Colts Neck, a charming and secluded township nestled in New Jersey’s Monmouth County, stands proudly as one of the most affluent neighborhoods in the region. It’s a prestigious address that attracts those seeking a tranquil suburban lifestyle amid a spectacular natural setting.
Read on to learn more about homes for sale in Colts Neck, NJ.
Escape the hustle and bustle of the city and breathe in the fresh air of Colts Neck. Here, you get to enjoy a peaceful retreat from the stress of big-city life without sacrificing modern conveniences.
The township is rife with expansive farms, meandering rustic country roads, and breathtaking woodlands, allowing residents to revel in the beauty of the great outdoors while enjoying all the comforts of modern living. Many grand estates here span around 6,000 square feet or more and sit on acres of land, ensuring exclusivity and lots of privacy.
Discover some of the most beautiful horse breeds at the numerous ranches scattered across the township. Explore sprawling orchards that bless the township with bountiful harvests. Immerse yourself in the invigorating breeze and embrace the small-town neighborhood vibe that sets this community apart. Here, you have the opportunity to build your dream home in a small corner of paradise within the Garden State.
Boasting seven prime neighborhoods, the Colts Neck real estate market offers a diverse range of options for different budgets, lifestyle requirements, and preferences.
Location
Colts Neck is strategically located at the heart of New Jersey, just 10 miles inland from Jersey Shore and a mere 45 miles south of the Big Apple. This central positioning is a notable advantage for individuals who frequently commute to New York for business and leisure.
The township is connected to neighboring towns and developments through key thoroughfares such as New Jersey Route 18, US Route 1 and 9, Garden State Parkway, and the New Jersey Turnpike/Interstate 95. Reaching destinations along the Jersey Shore takes around 30 minutes or less, while New York and Philadelphia are within an hour’s drive, making Colts Neck an ideal location for those employed in these major urban hubs.
What it is known for
Colts Neck boasts a selection of large properties, particularly horse training and breeding farms, lush fruit and nut orchards, and massive homes sitting on acres of land. The equestrian culture and lifestyle thrive in this affluent community, given the abundance of horse-related facilities and grazing grounds in the area.
Those with an active lifestyle will be drawn to the numerous golf courses in and around the area, the parks and open spaces, and the variety of outdoor activities to engage in. Meanwhile, for those who desire a quick beach retreat, Colts Neck is just a short drive away from some of the most beautiful and vibrant beaches in the area.
Indulge in the simple daily pleasures at Colts Neck’s thriving dining and shopping scenes, and exciting nightlife.
Colts Neck is also a preferred address by those seeking a promising environment for professional growth and success. The healthcare and technology sectors serve as the township’s primary economic drivers. Colts Neck also presents remarkable career opportunities in real estate, finance, law, tourism, retail, and hospitality, thanks to its strategic location that puts it near major towns and cities.
Basic facts
Colts Neck has a population reaching almost 10,000, according to 2022 U.S. Census estimates. The median household income here is at an impressive $187,969, significantly surpassing the national median.
Colts Neck may be small at under 32 square miles compared to its neighbors. However, approximately 30% of the area – equivalent to around 6,000 acres – is dedicated to over 300 farms, contributing to its picturesque rural charm. The remaining 7,300 acres consist of woodlands that enhance the township’s natural beauty and offer a tranquil environment.
Brief history
In the 1700s, this swath of land in Monmouth County was first known as Scobeyville until it was renamed to Colts Neck in 1856. While there’s no definite origin behind its name, some suggest that “Colts Neck” may be traced to the community’s rich heritage of horse breeding and farming. However, the name had already appeared in historical documents dating as far back as 1675, even before horse farms appeared in the area. Thus, the theory of the township’s shape resembling a colt’s neck also came to be.
Colts Neck was largely agricultural for most of its history until the 20th century when it gradually metamorphosed into a suburban development, fueled by the establishment of a Navy weapons station in the area in 1943. The said military base spurred the local economy as shops, food spots, and other establishments opened in its periphery to cater to the personnel stationed there.
Much has changed since Colts Neck’s agricultural origins. The township has turned into a high-end suburban oasis and an important gateway to major urban hubs in the Garden State, thanks to the efforts of its citizens and local officials who work to preserve its natural environment and historical heritage.
Colts Neck, NJ real estate is composed mainly of properties on huge plots of land, resulting in a low-density population. While some observers attribute this to a local zoning ordinance in Colts Neck that allegedly requires a minimum of 10 acres for residential construction, the said ordinance has been largely misunderstood. Section 102-85.1(C) and Section 102-85.2 of the township’s zoning code mention only five acres for single-family homes. The only time that the 10-acre minimum applies is if an institutional structure is built, like a school or church.
Moreover, the stringent zoning ordinances weren’t put in place simply to curb the population. As mentioned earlier, the township is pushing for the preservation of its natural surroundings. A sparse population allows for peaceful and balanced cohabitation between human settlements and the natural ecosystem that thrives in Colts Neck.
Available property types
If you’re in Colts Neck to explore luxury homes, you won’t be disappointed by the diverse array of residences ranging from charming ranches to stately Colonial-style mansions.. Newer luxury homes with up to 14 bedrooms, pools, gourmet kitchens, fully furnished outdoor spaces, and other special amenities are also available.
Apart from single-family homes for sale in Colts Neck, NJ, other common property types in Colts Neck include townhomes and condos. Some older, larger homes have been refurbished into multi-unit residences or apartments, adding to the available housing options.
Architectural styles, common and special amenities
The mansions in Colts Neck are stunning examples of architectural excellence and design. Drawing inspiration from diverse eras, the prevailing styles include Victorian, Tudor, Cape Cod, and Neoclassical influences.
Seizing the opportunity offered by sprawling lots, houses for sale in Colts Neck, NJ have interesting outdoor elements such as gazebos, meticulously landscaped gardens, winding driveways, and elegant fountains. Additionally, these homes feature family-centric amenities like pools, sports facilities, and grand courtyards, elevating the overall living experience.
Home interiors showcase the thoughtful use of spiral staircases, fireplaces, custom kitchens, and a palette dominated by neutral tones paired with organic yet sophisticated materials.
Colts Neck boasts a variety of charming neighborhoods, each offering unique qualities to suit different preferences.
Orchard Estates
Tailored for growing families, Orchard Estates is an exclusive, premier neighborhood composed of single-family homes with four to five bedrooms. Each home has 4,000 to 7,000 square feet of space for children and pets to have enough room to play. While many homes in this community were built in the 80s, they have been renovated and meticulously maintained to ensure excellent condition.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- Swimming pools
- Expansive outdoor entertainment areas
- Proximity to golf courses and clubs, Eastmont Orchards, the Dorbrook Recreation Area, and central Colts Neck
Hills Gait
Located near Big Brook Park and Boundary Road, this neighborhood features single-family homes with four to six bedrooms and five bathrooms. Offering 3,500 to 6,000 square feet of living space, many of these homes are equipped with swimming pools.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- Proximity to Big Brook Park which allows residents to easily engage in hiking, biking, camping, and other outdoor activities
- Proximity to the Vanderburg Soccer Complex and shopping, dining, and entertainment venues.
Carriage Hill
Located in the west of town, Carriage Hill is the perfect neighborhood for those who appreciate the allure of equestrian living. It consists of a select few lots of farmland spanning roughly 1.5 acres that are exclusively dedicated to horse breeding, boarding, and training centers. You’ll find grand mansions constructed in the 70s and ranch-style homes with up to seven bedrooms. Most homes here feature swimming pools.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- Swimming pools in almost every property
- Proximity to notable landmarks such as Durand Park, Cedar Drive Middle School, Colts Neck High School, and the Bucks Mill Recreation Area.
Clover Hill
Situated across Big Brook Park, Clover Hill is one of the larger communities in Colts Neck. It presents a diverse selection of single-family homes in various sizes ranging from 2,000 to 5,000 square feet. Whether you’re inclined towards smaller vintage properties from the 50s or expansive modern mansions, there’s a home for you in Clover Hill.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- The streams and woodlands that bring about a serene ambiance to the neighborhood
- Proximity to Holmdel and its restaurants and medical facilities.
The Grande
Considered one of the more affordable neighborhoods in Colts Neck, this neighborhood is thoughtfully designed with loops, short streets, and charming cul-de-sacs. The homes are smaller and sit side by side, fostering quick connections among neighbors. They feature three to four bedrooms and cover up to 3,000 square feet.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE
- Proximity to Orchard Hills Park, and Five Points Park
- Easy access to Hominy Hill Golf Course – considered one of the neighborhood’s finest golf courses.
Due Process Estates
Despite its peculiar name, Due Process is, in fact, a recently opened luxury residential enclave where lots occupy from 2 to 12 acres. Its name was taken from the nearby golf course, the name of which is – you guessed it – Due Process. It is also home to a welcoming community. Homes here feature five to seven bedrooms and range in size from 5,500 to over 13,000 square feet.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- Modern architecture and exquisite custom work
- Access to parks, playgrounds, and hiking trails at the Dorbrook Recreation Area and the Garden State Parkway
Phalanx Farms
Another oddly named community, Phalanx Farms boasts prime waterfront properties facing the Swimming River Reservoir. Residences here range from 2,000 to 9,000 square feet in size and typically feature three to six bedrooms. If you’re looking for homes with a lived-in feel and a lot of character, this neighborhood has lovely abodes built in the 70s; newer constructions from the early 2000s are also available.
WHAT YOU’LL LOVE:
- A close-knit community feel
- Access to the Garden State Parkway
- Water-based activities in the Swimming River Reservoir
If you have a passion for the outdoors, Colts Neck has an abundance of surprises and exciting experiences awaiting you – from scenic hiking trails and waterways to miles of woodland to explore. However, there’s more to Colts Neck than its intrinsic natural beauty. Below are more great things to expect when you live in Colts Neck, NJ.
Getting around
Traffic is not a problem in Colts Neck due to the sparse population in the township. However, the area is relatively car-centric, given the expansive lot sizes and the priority given to the preservation of its rural surroundings which limits public transportation options. However, biking is also a popular choice, offering a scenic and enjoyable way to traverse the area. Those looking to venture to New York City may hop on the North Jersey Coast Line Train or Seastreak Ferry via the Highlands area. Additionally, popular ridesharing services are readily accessible.
There is also the option to skip the land and water routes and travel by air via private plane at the Monmouth Jet Center.
Climate
Residents of Colts Neck experience the kind of climate that’s typical with New Jersey and the rest of the northeastern United States: a humid continental climate. Because of this, each of the four seasons is clearly defined by temperature changes. Winter temperatures can dip into the low 20s, with an average of around six inches of snow. March brings a gradual warming, accompanied by increased chances of rain. The summer season is characterized by relatively hot and very humid weather. The months leading up to fall offer pleasant and more comfortable temperatures.
Cost of living
Data from the Economic Research Institute shows that the cost of living in Colts Neck is higher than the state (+8%) and national (+29%) levels. However, the cost of labor here is also higher than the national average. Moreover, income tax rates in Colts Neck are among the lowest in the country. With residents having more money in their pockets, they could easily afford the high cost of living in this township. Add to that the exceptional quality of life and the unique amenities Colts Neck has to offer.
Job opportunities
Despite the high cost of living, Colts Neck balances this with a wealth of job opportunities. The local economy thrives, as evidenced by its low unemployment rates. While local companies like Laird & Company, a prominent liquor producer, provide employment opportunities, the majority of residents work in nearby towns and cities such as New York, Philadelphia, and other parts of New Jersey.
Schools
Colts Neck Township Schools – the school district that oversees the Conover Road Primary and Elementary Schools, as well as Cedar Drive Middle School – serves the public school students of Colts Neck. Meanwhile, Colts Neck High School in the Freehold Regional High School District caters to students up to Grade 12.
Nearby private schools include:
- Ranney School
- Trinity Hall
- Christian Brothers Academy
- Hillel Yeshiva School
For college education, these are the following options:
- Brookdale Community College
- Monmouth University
- Rutgers University
Attractions and activities
Colts Neck is an ideal destination for those longing for adventure with its diverse array of indoor and outdoor activities.
Nature enthusiasts may explore secure trails, fishing lakes, and intriguing architecture at Thompson Park. If you’re looking for a multifaceted recreational experience, Dorbrook Park Recreation Area is a must-visit, offering outdoor water parks, golf courses, sports facilities, and over 500 acres of woodland.
For some fun in the sun, the beaches of New Jersey are a mere 12-mile drive away. Explore the popular coastal destinations of Long Branch, Asbury Park, and Belmar.
For thrill-seekers and history buffs alike, nearby attractions such as Six Flags Great Adventure, the Six Flags Hurricane Harbor New Jersey, and the InfoAge Science and History Museums provide endless entertainment and learning opportunities.
Shopping and dining
Colts Neck isn’t just living it up in the Great Outdoors – it’s also about incredible lifestyle destinations, particularly in the retail and dining scene.
The Freehold Raceway Mall is the mall of choice here with its exciting shops, food spots, and recreation venues. Meanwhile, The Grove at Shrewsbury boasts a captivating mix of local boutiques and well-known brands.
Colts Neck also does not disappoint when it comes to good food and drinks. Here are some iconic hotspots to consider:
- 4JG, a local winery to try out handcrafted beer
- Huddy’s Inn
- Orlando Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Red Bank, the trendy district for nightlife fun
Eager to become the new owner of one of the luxury homes in Colts Neck, NJ? It makes sense to take on the services of an expert Realtor with years of experience serving home buyers, sellers, and investors in Monmouth County – someone like Mario Venancio. Let me share what I know with you so you could navigate the home-buying process in this lovely township with ease.
Let’s discuss your options in Colts Neck, NJ! Call me at 732.881.4306 or send me an email here.